Thursday, July 31, 2025

Drug Test vs. Nothing to See Here

Your Champion
Drug Test
(The Faculty)

VS

Your Challenger
Nothing to See Here
(The Naked Gun)

The Case for Drug Test (1):
In this homage to The Thing, the teenage protagonists must take a drug to prove they have not been taken over by aliens, since at least one of them has likely been.

The Case for Nothing to See Here:
Chasing down an (unknown to him) hypnotized doctor, Frank Drebin (Leslie Nielsen) tries to steer away the crowd that has gathered after two car and one building explosion.


The Score: Nothing to See Here 6, Drug Test 5

Have a suggestion?  Read the rules and send me an email!  Also be sure to check out the Hall of Fame to see retired scenes and who they defeated!

Wednesday, July 30, 2025

Whistle While You Work vs. Drug Test

Your Champion
Whistle While You Work
(Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs)

VS

Your Challenger
Drug Test
(The Faculty)

The Case for Whistle While You Work (1):
A nice tune does help the work go faster...

The Case for Drug Test:
In this homage to The Thing, the teenage protagonists must take a drug to prove they have not been taken over by aliens, since at least one of them has likely been.


The Score: Drug Test 8, Whistle While You Work 6

Have a suggestion?  Read the rules and send me an email!  Also be sure to check out the Hall of Fame to see retired scenes and who they defeated!

Tuesday, July 29, 2025

Savage Comeback vs. Whistle While You Work

Your Champion
Savage Comeback
(Sleepaway Camp)

VS

Your Challenger
Whistle While You Work
(Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs)

The Case for Savage Comeback (2):
There isn't any recovery from Ricky's (Jonathan Tiersten) response here - Billy (Loris Sallahian) might survive for a few more scenes, but the real murder happened on the baseball field.

The Case for Whistle While You Work:
A nice tune does help the work go faster...


The Score: Whistle While You Work 7, Savage Comeback 6

Have a suggestion?  Read the rules and send me an email!  Also be sure to check out the Hall of Fame to see retired scenes and who they defeated!

Monday, July 28, 2025

Savage Comeback vs. Nothing Small Into a Bar

Your Champion
Savage Comeback
(Sleepaway Camp)

VS

Your Challenger
Nothing Small Into a Bar
(Harvey)

The Case for Savage Comeback (1):
There isn't any recovery from Ricky's (Jonathan Tiersten) response here - Billy (Loris Sallahian) might survive for a few more scenes, but the real murder happened on the baseball field.

The Case for Nothing Small Into a Bar:
"Nobody ever brings anything small into a bar..."


The Score: Savage Comeback 7, Nothing Small Into a Bar 3

Have a suggestion?  Read the rules and send me an email!  Also be sure to check out the Hall of Fame to see retired scenes and who they defeated!

Sunday, July 27, 2025

Wrecked vs. Savage Comeback

Your Champion
Wrecked
(Final Destination 2)

VS

Your Challenger
Savage Comeback
(Sleepaway Camp)

The Case for Wrecked (6):
In a scene that scarred a generation - possibly because of all the practical effects used - we meet the main group of characters we'll be interacting with this movie, and the premonition that shows the fate they managed to avoid.

The Case for Savage Comeback:
There isn't any recovery from Ricky's (Jonathan Tiersten) response here - Billy (Loris Sallahian) might survive for a few more scenes, but the real murder happened on the baseball field.


The Score: Savage Comeback 6, Wrecked 5

Have a suggestion?  Read the rules and send me an email!  Also be sure to check out the Hall of Fame to see retired scenes and who they defeated!

Thursday, July 24, 2025

Wrecked vs. Going Supernova

Your Champion
Wrecked
(Final Destination 2)

VS

Your Challenger
Going Supernova
(Fantastic Four)

The Case for Wrecked (5):
In a scene that scarred a generation - possibly because of all the practical effects used - we meet the main group of characters we'll be interacting with this movie, and the premonition that shows the fate they managed to avoid.

The Case for Going Supernova:
Working as a team, the Fantastic Four (Michael Chiklis, Jessica Alba, Chris Evans, and Ioan Gruffudd) do what they can to stop Dr. Doom (Julian McMahon) - with Mr. Fantastic telling Johnny Storm to throw caution to the wind when it comes to his limits.


The Score: Wrecked 7, Going Supernova 4

Have a suggestion?  Read the rules and send me an email!  Also be sure to check out the Hall of Fame to see retired scenes and who they defeated!

Wednesday, July 23, 2025

Wrecked vs. Turning Heads

Your Champion
Wrecked
(Final Destination 2)

VS

Your Challenger
Turning Heads
(The Exorcist)

The Case for Wrecked (4):
In a scene that scarred a generation - possibly because of all the practical effects used - we meet the main group of characters we'll be interacting with this movie, and the premonition that shows the fate they managed to avoid.

The Case for Turning Heads:
As Father Merrin (Max von Sydow) and Father Karras (Jason Miller) try to force the demon out of Regan (Linda Blair, with Mercedes McCambridge providing the voice), Father Karras watches impossible things happen as the demon tries to distract the priests from their mission.


The Score: Wrecked 9, Turning Heads 5

Have a suggestion?  Read the rules and send me an email!  Also be sure to check out the Hall of Fame to see retired scenes and who they defeated!

Tuesday, July 22, 2025

Wrecked vs. Caught in a Web

Your Champion
Wrecked
(Final Destination 2)

VS

Your Challenger
Caught in a Web
(Enemy)

The Case for Wrecked (3):
In a scene that scarred a generation - possibly because of all the practical effects used - we meet the main group of characters we'll be interacting with this movie, and the premonition that shows the fate they managed to avoid.

The Case for Caught in a Web:
Having replaced his exact twin Anthony, Adam (Jake Gyllenhaal in a dual role) decides to step out for the night.  His now-wife Helen (Sarah Gadon) has stepped away, and when he goes to check on her, the movie ends on his unexpected discovery.


The Score: Wrecked 10, Caught in a Web 3

Have a suggestion?  Read the rules and send me an email!  Also be sure to check out the Hall of Fame to see retired scenes and who they defeated!

Monday, July 21, 2025

Wrecked vs. Snack Sabotage

Your Champion
Wrecked
(Final Destination 2)

VS

Your Challenger
Snack Sabotage
(K-POP Demon Hunters)

The Case for Wrecked (2):
In a scene that scarred a generation - possibly because of all the practical effects used - we meet the main group of characters we'll be interacting with this movie, and the premonition that shows the fate they managed to avoid.

The Case for Snack Sabotage:
Demon hunters and K-Pop idols Rumi, Zoey, and Mira are partaking in their favorite pre-show ritual when they realize they're being sabotaged.
(Submitted by Renée and Mary)


The Score: Wrecked 6, Snack Sabotage 2

Have a suggestion?  Read the rules and send me an email!  Also be sure to check out the Hall of Fame to see retired scenes and who they defeated!

Sunday, July 20, 2025

Wrecked vs. Fighting Paddy

Your Champion
Wrecked
(Final Destination 2)

VS

Your Challenger
Fighting Paddy
(Charlie's Angels: Full Throttle)

The Case for Wrecked (1):
In a scene that scarred a generation - possibly because of all the practical effects used - we meet the main group of characters we'll be interacting with this movie, and the premonition that shows the fate they managed to avoid.

The Case for Fighting Paddy:
While the first movie was lighter on the satire, the sequel leaned hard into it: This isn't even the most over-the-top fight of the movie - with everything else (the dialogue, the music, the camera spins) also turned up to eleven to give the film a consistent tone.


The Score: Wrecked 8, Fighting Paddy 6

Have a suggestion?  Read the rules and send me an email!  Also be sure to check out the Hall of Fame to see retired scenes and who they defeated!

Thursday, July 17, 2025

Only When It Was Funny vs. Wrecked

Your Champion
Only When It Was Funny
(Who Framed Roger Rabbit?)

VS

Your Challenger
Wrecked
(Final Destination 2)

The Case for Only When It Was Funny (3):
Hey, he can't help it if he has to live by Toon rules!

The Case for Wrecked:
In a scene that scarred a generation - possibly because of all the practical effects used - we meet the main group of characters we'll be interacting with this movie, and the premonition that shows the fate they managed to avoid.


The Score:  Wrecked 6, Only When It Was Funny 5

Have a suggestion?  Read the rules and send me an email!  Also be sure to check out the Hall of Fame to see retired scenes and who they defeated!

Wednesday, July 16, 2025

Only When It Was Funny vs. LA, Destroyed

Your Champion
Only When It Was Funny
(Who Framed Roger Rabbit?)

VS

Your Challenger
LA, Destroyed
(2012)

The Case for Only When It Was Funny (2):
Hey, he can't help it if he has to live by Toon rules!

The Case for LA, Destroyed:
Granted, it gets destroyed eventually, but I'm sure New York City was happy another metro area got the mass destruction treatment.


The Score: Only When It Was Funny 8, LA, Destroyed 5

Have a suggestion?  Read the rules and send me an email!  Also be sure to check out the Hall of Fame to see retired scenes and who they defeated!

Tuesday, July 15, 2025

Only When It Was Funny vs. Benny's a Good Dog

Your Champion
Only When It Was Funny
(Who Framed Roger Rabbit?)

VS

Your Challenger
Benny's a Good Dog
(The War of the Roses)

The Case for Only When It Was Funny (1):
Hey, he can't help it if he has to live by Toon rules!

The Case for Benny's a Good Dog:
Barbara (Kathleen Turner) really, really didn't want to stay married to stay married to Oliver (Michael Douglas).


The Score:  Only When It Was Funny 7, Benny's a Good Dog 6

Have a suggestion?  Read the rules and send me an email!  Also be sure to check out the Hall of Fame to see retired scenes and who they defeated!

Monday, July 14, 2025

Mahjong vs. Only When It Was Funny

Your Champion
Mahjong
(Crazy Rich Asians)

VS

Your Challenger
Only When It Was Funny
(Who Framed Roger Rabbit?)

The Case for Mahjong (1):
In this climactic scene, Rachel (Constance Wu) plays mahjong against Eleanor (Michelle Yeoh) while discussing her relationship with Nick (Henry Golding).  As the game is played, Rachel confronts Eleanor about her treatment, and also lets Eleanor know that she is bowing out not because she can't win, but because Eleanor has made sure that Nick loses - demonstrating her point within the game as well.

The Case for Only When It Was Funny:
Hey, he can't help it if he has to live by Toon rules!


The Score: Only When It Was Funny 9, Mahjong 5

Have a suggestion?  Read the rules and send me an email!  Also be sure to check out the Hall of Fame to see retired scenes and who they defeated!

Sunday, July 13, 2025

Fate Refused vs. Mahjong

Your Champion
Fate Refused
(No Country for Old Men)

VS

Your Challenger
Mahjong
(Crazy Rich Asians)

The Case for Fate Refused (1):
Coming home to find Chigurh (Javier Barden) in her house, Carla Jean (Kelly Macdonald) pleads for her life despite knowing how unlikely it was she would be spared.  Given the opportunity to decide her fate by coin, Carle Jean refuses - forcing Chigurh to make the decision himself.

The Case for Mahjong:
In this climactic scene, Rachel (Constance Wu) plays mahjong against Eleanor (Michelle Yeoh) while discussing her relationship with Nick (Henry Golding).  As the game is played, Rachel confronts Eleanor about her treatment, and also lets Eleanor know that she is bowing out not because she can't win, but because Eleanor has made sure that Nick loses - demonstrating her point within the game as well.


The Score: Mahjong 7, Fate Refused 4

Have a suggestion?  Read the rules and send me an email!  Also be sure to check out the Hall of Fame to see retired scenes and who they defeated!

Thursday, July 10, 2025

Time's Up vs. Fate Refused

Your Champion
Time's Up
(Independence Day)

VS

Your Challenger
Fate Refused
(No Country for Old Men)

The Case for Time's Up (5):
With it's 'Alien Invasion as Disaster Movie' premise, Independence Day hits its Act 1 climax as the aliens unleash their attacks on the world.

The Case for Fate Refused:
Coming home to find Chigurh (Javier Barden) in her house, Carla Jean (Kelly Macdonald) pleads for her life despite knowing how unlikely it was she would be spared.  Given the opportunity to decide her fate by coin, Carle Jean refuses - forcing Chigurh to make the decision himself.


The Score: Fate Refused 6, Time's Up 5

Have a suggestion?  Read the rules and send me an email!  Also be sure to check out the Hall of Fame to see retired scenes and who they defeated!

Wednesday, July 9, 2025

Time's Up vs. Where There's a Whip, There's a Way

Your Champion
Time's Up
(Independence Day)

VS

Your Challenger
Where There's a Whip, There's a Way
(The Return of the King)

The Case for Time's Up (4):
With it's 'Alien Invasion as Disaster Movie' premise, Independence Day hits its Act 1 climax as the aliens unleash their attacks on the world.

The Case for Where There's a Whip, There's a Way:
"We don't wanna go to war today, but the Lord of the Lash says 'Nay, nay, nay!'"


The Score: Time's Up 9, Where There's a Whip, There's a Way 7

Have a suggestion?  Read the rules and send me an email!  Also be sure to check out the Hall of Fame to see retired scenes and who they defeated!

Tuesday, July 8, 2025

Time's Up vs. I'm Tired

Your Champion
Time's Up
(Independence Day)

VS

Your Challenger
I'm Tired
(Blazing Saddles)

The Case for Time's Up (3):
With it's 'Alien Invasion as Disaster Movie' premise, Independence Day hits its Act 1 climax as the aliens unleash their attacks on the world.

The Case for I'm Tired:
In this combination tribute/send up of Marlene Dietrich, patrons gather around to see the famous 'Teutonic Titwillow' Lili Von Shtupp (Madeline Kahn) give a performance of 'I'm Tired.'


The Score: Time's Up 11, I'm Tired 6

Have a suggestion?  Read the rules and send me an email!  Also be sure to check out the Hall of Fame to see retired scenes and who they defeated!

Monday, July 7, 2025

Time's Up vs. News Rumble

Your Champion
Time's Up
(Independence Day)

VS

Your Challenger
News Rumble
(Anchorman: The Legend of Ron Burgundy)

The Case for Time's Up (2):
With it's 'Alien Invasion as Disaster Movie' premise, Independence Day hits its Act 1 climax as the aliens unleash their attacks on the world.

The Case for News Rumble:
"Boy, that escalated quickly."


The Score: Time's Up 9, News Rumble 5

Have a suggestion?  Read the rules and send me an email!  Also be sure to check out the Hall of Fame to see retired scenes and who they defeated!

Sunday, July 6, 2025

Time's Up vs. Stuck in the Middle with You

Your Champion
Time's Up
(Independence Day)

VS

Your Challenger
Stuck in the Middle with You
(Reservoir Dogs)

The Case for Time's Up (1):
With it's 'Alien Invasion as Disaster Movie' premise, Independence Day hits its Act 1 climax as the aliens unleash their attacks on the world.

The Case for Stuck in the Middle with You:
Director Quentin Tarantino had actors audition with this song, knowing that he was going to use it once filming began.  And when Mr. Blonde (Michael Madsen) begins his torture of Officer Nash (Kirk Baltz), it is the music that plays during the horrific scene.


The Score: Time's Up 7, Stuck in the Middle with You 6

Have a suggestion?  Read the rules and send me an email!  Also be sure to check out the Hall of Fame to see retired scenes and who they defeated!

Best Friends vs. End of His Rope

Your Champion Best Friends ( Scary Movie 2 ) VS Your Challenger End of His Rope ( The Mist ) The Case for Best Friends (3) : "I thought...